Read an interesting, if not pointless bit of journalism on CNN today. Basically, Jack Cafferty is questioning the Obama administration’s choice to use higher taxes to the rich to help pay for health care reform. While questioning the government’s decisions is something we should always do, the tone that political journalists take in regard to that questioning is just as important. Sensational news stories that are nothing short of flame bait have become the norm these days, and frankly, it’s sickening. There is so little actual information or “news” in Cafferty’s piece, that one needs to consider whether it belongs on a news site at all. In any case, it riled me enough to make me think about the issue again.
Should the wealthy help pay for healthcare? Notice that I used the word “help”. Cafferty did not. The rich can not, will not pay for the entire changes called for by the Obama administration, so it is completely disingenuous to imply that they will. My money will go toward the new system, as will anyone with income in the U.S.
Cafferty suggests that under the new plan, someone making $450,000 a year, will pay $7,100 more in taxes. $7,100 sounds like a lot… if you’re making less than $50,000 a year. But he should have used percentages. In percentages, that’s about 1.57% more taxes. Not really that exciting, is it. To really put it in perspective, do it the other way. If I made $45,000 a year (what most of us do), that would be an extra $710 more a year in taxes. While it would certainly hurt a little, it still sounds like a deal. And that’s the higher rate for the rich, the ones for whom an extra $7100 is peanuts.
Is it fair? Simply put, no. But I do think it’s just. Putting a slightly higher burden on a slim few who are doing well is not much to make such a huge difference in the lives of so many. I don’t buy the crap that the wealthy have worked harder to get where they are and shouldn’t be penalized for that by paying for those that simply “sit around and expect the government to take care of them”. First of all, that attitude is insulting to anyone with a disability, and second, the rich, for the most part, are rich because they stand on the backs of the shuffling hordes who DO work harder, literally, and for wages that pretty much ensure that they will never have that “American Dream.” If the middle class fails, we ALL fail.
HOWEVER, I am amazed that no one is really asking the right question here, which is not, should the rich pay, but rather what is really wrong with healthcare. Why is it that Americans are going bankrupt over health issues that weren’t a problem 50 years ago? Or even 10 years ago. Are we suddenly less healthy? To a certain degree, I think we are, but not proportionally to the amounts we’re paying in health cost today. Not even close. So what’s really up? Where is that money going?
The ones getting fat off of unhealthy Americans are the ones who provide the care. Hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, high-tech medical research. More than any other time in our history, our doctors are prescribing procedures that cost hundreds of times more than anything our parents ever paid. The medical industry would say that these new, expensive procedures are there to save lives. Unfortunately, they are fixing the body, and leaving the soul in the gutter. It’s not uncommon for a doctor to ask for a $6,000 MRI head scan whenever a patient complains of even minor neck pain after a car accident. Sure, it can really confirm if there’s something wrong, and so can waiting a week to see if the pain goes away. Doctors are getting kickbacks from big pharma to push the latest and greatest medications, which incidentally aren’t covered by any health care, let alone government issue, all when there are perfectly acceptable and proven alternatives already on the market. Is it really worth that $400 a month for 30 pills for slightly fewer side effects? We have stopped treating causes and only treat symptoms. Who cares why I have acid reflux, so long as I can take a pill (for the rest of my life) and feel better. It’s actually hard to find someone over fifty who ISN’T taking at least one long term medication. What does that say about us?
We treat our personal physicians the same way we treat our auto mechanic. We go in when something breaks, and we don’t care how it works (or even what’s wrong for the most part). We just want them to fix the problem so we can get back out on the road and continue doing whatever it was that broke the car in the first place. The only time we actually want to know the details is when the mechanic tells us that the bill is going to exceed the Bluebook value of the car. Ah, and that’s where the analogy parts ways, because we have been taught that your simply can’t put a price on life.
And yet we do. Our doctor certainly does, likewise our insurance company. Our life insurance is literally putting a price tag on our life. So what is our health really worth? Should the poor be left to die because they cant afford an expensive CT scan or the medications that could save their life?
Who is regulating the medical industry? Who sets the prices that doctors and surgeons charge for services, or is it simply “what the market will bear”? I heard on the radio that the government wants to work with the medical industry to get them to lower costs by streamlining things. They were asking them to agree to cut costs by 10 and 20% over several decades… And they would do this because…? Why should they agree to less profit? Why should they agree to do 20% worse financially in the coming years? It looks nice in front of the media, that’s for sure, but it’s all just vapor. A little creative accounting will make the shareholders smile again, and THAT is what really matters to the medical industry. You can’t put a price on happy shareholders. Screw life. Screw the American public. If it wasn’t profitable, it wouldn’t be the American Way. At least that’s how the pharmaceutical industry sees it.
So, Jack, instead of flaming the Obama administration for making the “rich” pay more for new healthcare, why don’t you turn that ire on the ones who have their hands out to collect?